Skip to main content
Cover of The Secret History
Read

The Secret History

by Donna Tartt

Rated 3.5 out of 5Alison's rating

A group of eccentric classics students at a Vermont college become entangled in the cover-up of a murder they themselves committed.

Add to my library
The Messy Reader verdict

Exquisite prose let down by languid pacing

Reviewed 12 January 2025 messyreaderby messyreader Spoiler free

Donna Tartt's "The Secret History" undeniably showcases a masterful command of language and character development. The prose is exquisite, imbued with a poetic rhythm that elevates the narrative. Tartt meticulously crafts a cast of enigmatic and complex individuals, each grappling with desires, insecurities, and the seductive allure of forbidden knowledge. Richard, the narrator, emerges as a particularly compelling figure, his voice imbued with a captivating blend of naivet? and disillusionment.

However, the novel's deliberate pacing often borders on the languid. The extended ruminations on Greek mythology and philosophy, while undoubtedly contributing to the novel's intellectual depth, can feel ponderous and slow the narrative momentum. The suspense, though palpable at times, is frequently overshadowed by the languid introspection of the characters.

Despite these reservations, "The Secret History" remains a significant work of contemporary literature. Tartt's profound exploration of themes such as ambition, guilt, and the corrupting influence of beauty makes it a novel worthy of close attention. However, readers seeking a fast-paced thriller may find themselves frustrated by its leisurely pace.

Also on Instagram