Skip to main content
Cover of We All Want Impossible Things
Read

We All Want Impossible Things

by Catherine Newman

Rated 4 out of 5Alison's rating

A poignant and moving novel beautifully capturing the complexities of lifelong friendship as one friend faces a terminal illness.

The Messy Reader verdict

A poignant celebration of friendship and love

Reviewed 20 January 2025 messyreaderby messyreader Spoiler free

Catherine Newman's "We All Want Impossible Things" is a poignant and moving novel that beautifully captures the complexities of lifelong friendship. The story centers around Edi, who is terminally ill, and her best friend Ash, who grapples with the impending loss of her dearest companion.

Newman masterfully portrays the emotional rollercoaster of grief and acceptance. The novel delves deep into the nuances of their decades-long bond, showcasing the joys, the challenges, and the unwavering love that defines their relationship. While undeniably sad, the story is ultimately uplifting, celebrating the power of friendship and the importance of cherishing the time we have with loved ones.

The themes of terminal illness and loss may be emotionally challenging for some readers. The pace of the story is at times a little haphazard. This being said, it was an excellent read which I do recommend.

This novel made me think about my relationships, and it had me reaching for my phone to text my best friend at the end (through the tears and sobs, of course).

Also on Instagram